Your next customer might not Google you. They might ask ChatGPT, Gemini or Perplexity. We wanted to know what those engines actually say about Nova Scotia businesses, so we tested 30 of them. We have been tracking this shift since ChatGPT opened business listings in November.
The headline numbers
We asked each engine one question per business, the way a customer would ask it. "Best luxury hotel in Halifax." "Best roofing company in Halifax." "Best dentist in Halifax." Thirty businesses, three engines, ninety answers.
5 of 30 businesses were invisible everywhere. They did not appear in any engine's answer. That is 17%.
6 of 30 were recommended by all three engines. That is 20%.
25 of 30 showed up on at least one engine. That is 83%.
ChatGPT recommended far more businesses than the other two. It put 22 of 30 on its recommended list. Perplexity and Gemini each recommended 10.
The engines do not agree with each other. That matters, because a customer only asks one of them.
The invisible five
These businesses did not appear in any of the three engines’ answers:
Domus Realty (real estate, Halifax)
Classic Roofing & Siding (construction, Dartmouth)
Citadel Physiotherapy (health, Halifax)
Modern Age Aesthetics & Wellness (health, Halifax)
Seagulf Marine Industries (marine, Dartmouth)
And these six were recommended by all three:
What we found by sector
Nonprofits were the most visible group in the sample. All three were recommended by all three engines, nine out of nine. Tourism and food and beverage were strong too. Hotels and restaurants mostly showed up, and mostly near the top.
Real estate and construction were the weakest. Perplexity recommended none of the six real estate and construction businesses we tested. Gemini recommended none of them either. ChatGPT was kinder, but the pattern across the other two engines was clear.
Health and wellness was split. Atlantic Dental Centre was a top pick on ChatGPT and Perplexity, and invisible on Gemini. The other two health businesses in the sample were invisible almost everywhere.
The engines see different businesses
This was the most surprising part. The same business can be a top pick on one engine and invisible on another.
Frida Fine Jewellery was invisible on Perplexity and Gemini. On ChatGPT it was the number one pick, "my pick." Riva Construction and Harbour View Electrical were invisible on both Perplexity and Gemini, and in ChatGPT's top five. Dexel Developments was invisible on Perplexity and Gemini, and number two on ChatGPT.
So a business can be doing everything right for one engine and still be missing from the other two. Visibility is not one score. It is three different answers to the same question.
The basics are mostly missing
Before we tested the engines, we checked each business’s website for the basics AI engines use.
Only 7 of 30 had an llms.txt file, the file that tells AI crawlers what a business is. Six of those seven were auto-generated by Shopify or Wix, not written by the business.
Only 13 of 30 had a blog post from 2026. Only 13 of 30 had a visible FAQ.
One site, Cox & Palmer, actively blocks AI crawlers in its robots.txt.
But the basics do not predict the result cleanly. Classic Roofing had an llms.txt file, a 2026 blog and a FAQ, and was still invisible on all three engines. Having the file is not enough. The engines seem to care more about who else mentions you, and how often, than about what your own site says.
What this means for a Nova Scotia business
A customer asking an AI engine is asking a different question than a customer typing into Google. Google shows you a list. An AI engine gives you an answer, usually with three to five names. If you are not one of them, you are not in the running.
Three things stood out in the results.
First, being mentioned somewhere other than your own website matters. The businesses the engines recommended most often were the ones with press coverage, directory listings, awards and reviews elsewhere on the web. Your own site is the starting point, not the whole story.
Second, fresh content helps, but it is not the deciding factor. The nonprofits in our sample publish often, and they were the most visible group. But several businesses with current blogs were still invisible.
Third, check all three engines, not one. The gaps between them were bigger than we expected. A business that looks fine on ChatGPT can be missing entirely on Gemini.
Google's Preferred Sources feature can also highlight a site's content in Top Stories and in AI Overviews.
How we tested this
Thirty Nova Scotia businesses, Halifax-area first, three per sector across ten sectors we work in: tourism and hospitality, food and beverage, retail, professional services, real estate and property, construction and trades, manufacturing, health and wellness, marine, and nonprofits and associations. Growing, owner-led businesses, roughly $1 to $5 million in revenue, with a real website. No Charcoal clients in the sample.
Each engine got the same 30 questions, one per business, asked the way a customer would ask. Each question ran in a fresh chat so earlier answers could not influence later ones. We recorded whether the business was recommended, mentioned, cited with a link to its own site, or invisible. Perplexity and Gemini were tested signed in as a work Google account. ChatGPT was tested on its free plan, signed in with the same work account. All testing happened on November 16, 2026.
Caveats
AI answers change. Ask the same question tomorrow and the list can shift. We tested one question per business, not several, and we did not test the second, more direct set of prompts we prepared. One Perplexity result was a location miss, it answered about Dartmouth, Massachusetts instead of Dartmouth, Nova Scotia, and we counted it as invalid rather than invisible. This is a snapshot of one day, not a permanent ranking.
We will repeat this test, and we expect the numbers to move.